The Sci-Fi Rabbi - Exploring Jewish Wisdom
and Speculative Fiction
Make It So
I’m still reeling from the news of Patrick Stewart’s passing.
I was twelve years old when Star Trek: The Next Generation first aired and I definitely did NOT approve of the new Enterprise or her captain. The ship looked unbalanced and oddly delicate, with its small nacelles feeling out of proportion. And after William Shatner’s portrayal of James T. Kirk, Patrick Stewart seemed absurdly old. Jean-Luc Picard felt like a letdown.
When the Kirk-versus-Picard battles emerged, I was definitely on Team Kirk.
Bit by bit, as I grew a little older, I became more willing to recognize that some problems require reflection and diplomacy. Picard listened carefully. He sought out different opinions. When the answers he received didn’t satisfy him, he looked deeper.
By “The Best of Both Worlds,” I was completely hooked. I felt fury at the Borg for taking this captain whom I had grown first to like, then to respect, and finally to love, and twisting him into something evil. Realizing that I would have to wait months to learn how the story ended was heartbreaking.
Over time, Picard became a model for the kind of man I hoped to become. He was an artist, a romantic, and a scholar. He tempered sternness with compassion and action with intellect. He possessed tremendous authority, yet never seemed to hunger for glory. When the work was done, he seemed perfectly content to putter around at home with a cup of Earl Grey.
And my goodness, that voice.
I had the privilege of hearing Sir Patrick in person only once. My grandmother and I shared a passion for theater, although she despaired of my love for science fiction and fantasy. One Chanukah, while visiting her in New York, she told me that she had bought tickets for us.
“What are we going to see?” I asked.
“Oh, it’s your friend who is in a show,” she replied. “The one who acts in Star Wars.”
For a moment, I could not figure out what she meant. Then I burst into laughter and explained the distinction.
She shrugged, as if to say, “Star Wars, Star Trek. It’s all the same.”
The show was Sir Patrick Stewart’s solo performance of A Christmas Carol. My grandmother made it clear that she did not expect much from him.
Sir Patrick held the entire room spellbound. Through his gestures, expressions, and vocal inflections, an entire cast unfolded before us. By the end, my grandmother was comparing him to Derek Jacobi, whom we both held in extraordinarily high regard.
That magical evening remains one of my favorite memories of my grandmother, and I will always be grateful to Sir Patrick for giving it to us.
Picard would never have described himself as living by Jewish values. Still, I recognized something deeply familiar in him. Pirkei Avot 4:1 asks, “Who is mighty?” and answers, “The one who subdues their own inclination.”
Picard’s true strength wasn’t that he never got angry or fearful, or even that he never felt self-doubt. I was inspired by the discipline with which he struggled to govern them. The Borg broke him, and the Cardassians broke him again. In First Contact, his anger almost consumed him before he found his way back to himself.
Picard’s self-command touched me. I saw him projecting discipline more than serenity. That made him human. It also gave me a vision of masculinity that could accommodate fear, uncertainty, and weakness without surrendering the capacity for tenderness or wonder.
Sir Patrick helped science fiction grow and mature right alongside me. Through Jean-Luc Picard, he gave me an example of adulthood rooted in thoughtfulness, curiosity, and moral courage. In many ways, that’s the role model for who I am still striving to become.
When I was twelve, I knew exactly who my favorite captain was. And now I know better. It’s not Kirk-versus-Picard.
It’s Kirk and Picard.
